Best Toffee Pairings: Coffee, Tea, and More

Best Toffee Pairings: Coffee, Tea, and More

Toffee isn’t just for snacking—it’s made for pairing. Whether you’re enjoying a quiet cup of coffee, sipping tea with friends, or looking for a sweet touch after dinner, Toffee Temptations toffee brings an extra layer of indulgence to the moment.

Here are our favorite drink (and snack!) pairings to enjoy with your favorite flavors.

☕ Coffee + Toffee = A Match Made in Heaven

Coffee’s natural bitterness is the perfect balance to toffee’s buttery sweetness. Whether you brew a bold dark roast or a smooth latte, these combinations shine:

  • Cappuccino Toffee + a hot espresso or iced oat milk latte
    → Vanilla toffee and white chocolate meet bold espresso notes = bliss.

  • Almond Dark Chocolate Toffee + black coffee
    → The roasted almonds and dark chocolate layer beautifully with a rich cup of drip.

  • Pistachio Milk Chocolate Toffee + caramel macchiato
    → The creaminess of milk chocolate and the nutty crunch pairs perfectly with sweet, frothy coffee.

🍵 Tea + Toffee: Light, Floral, and Cozy

For a softer pairing, tea brings out subtle notes in your toffee and makes every bite feel a little more elegant.

  • Lemon Lavender Toffee + Earl Grey or chamomile
    → Floral meets floral. Soothing and fragrant, with dried lemon peel and lavender buds on top.

  • Banoffee Toffee + chai or spiced black tea
    → Banana and toffee meet warming spices—comfort in every bite.

  • Almond White Chocolate Toffee + green tea or jasmine
    → Sweet and buttery toffee with delicate, grassy tea makes for a balanced, refreshing pairing.

🍷 Toffee with Wine, Cider & More

Pairing toffee with wine or after-dinner drinks? Yes, please.

  • Cardamom Orange Toffee + mulled wine or spiced cider
    → Citrus and spice blend beautifully with warm, cozy drinks.

  • Pistachio Dark Chocolate Toffee + ruby port or red wine
    → Dark chocolate and nuts shine against rich, fruity reds.

  • Almond Milk Chocolate Toffee + a glass of bourbon or dark rum
    → Sweet, nutty, and just indulgent enough for a special night in.

🧀 Bonus: Sweet & Savory Pairings

For the adventurous snackers:

  • Banoffee Toffee with aged cheddar

  • Lemon Lavender Toffee with creamy goat cheese

  • Cappuccino Toffee crumbled over vanilla ice cream

Sweet meets savory in surprising, delicious ways.

✨ How Will You Pair Yours?

Our toffee is made for sharing, sipping, and savoring—no matter the season or setting. Try your favorite combination and let us know what works best in your cup or on your plate.

👉 Explore our full flavor collection and discover your perfect pairing.