Flavor Experiments: Meet Our Most Exciting Toffee Creations
At Toffee Temptations, we love the classics—but we’re just as obsessed with exploring unexpected and exciting flavor combinations that go way beyond traditional toffee.
Each new recipe starts with the same buttery toffee base (cooked slowly to 295°F for that perfect snap) and builds on it with bold extracts, unique toppings, and carefully chosen chocolate pairings.
Here’s a peek at some of our newest—and most creative—flavors that are tempting taste buds all across Maryland:
🍌 Banoffee Toffee
Inspired by the classic British dessert, this one combines banana extract in the toffee base, a smooth white chocolate topping, and crunchy freeze-dried bananas with a toffee crumble finish.
Why it works: The sweet creaminess of banana + buttery toffee + light crunch = indulgent and playful.
🍋 Lemon Lavender White Chocolate Toffee
Fragrant lavender and zesty lemon extracts are blended into the base, then topped with creamy white chocolate, dried lemon peel, and real lavender buds.
Why it works: Bright and floral, this toffee feels like a bite of spring—delicate, elegant, and totally unique.
🍊 Orange Cardamom Dark Chocolate Toffee
Fresh orange extract in the toffee base, topped with 60% dark chocolate and sprinkled with ground cardamom. Warm, rich, and aromatic.
Why it works: The citrus lifts the chocolate, while cardamom adds depth. A cozy, spiced favorite.
☕ Cappuccino Toffee
A vanilla-infused toffee base topped with white chocolate and finished with a dusting of espresso powder.
Why it works: Think coffee shop in a bite—smooth, creamy, and satisfying with a gentle caffeine kick.
🍎 Apple Cinnamon Milk Chocolate Toffee
Apple and cinnamon extracts in the base, topped with milk chocolate, freeze-dried apple, and a light sprinkle of ground cinnamon.
Why it works: Comforting and warm—like apple pie in toffee form. Perfect with tea or cider.
🌱 More Coming Soon...
We’re always working on new flavor ideas—some seasonal, some just for fun. Whether it’s Chai Spice, Matcha Citrus, or Hazelnut Espresso, we’re constantly testing and tasting to keep things fresh and exciting.
✨ Want to Help Choose the Next Flavor?
Follow us on Instagram to vote in upcoming flavor polls, be the first to hear about drops, and even test new flavors before they go live on the site.
Craving something new?
Shop all our current flavors here—and check back often for the latest creations.